Worked Examples and Optional Depth
Use these cards after the corresponding core teaching. They supply the scenario and a sample response; no external research, new account, real-world contact, or private disclosure is required. The examples are fictional teaching cases, not real measurements, medical guidance, legal rulings, financial advice, or promises of outcomes.
Two kinds of optional work
- Supplied practice: the scenario, sample response, and depth question are on this page. Allow about 15–20 minutes for one card, with paper or oral explanation. Read the card before the session; a calculator is optional for arithmetic.
- Open research prompt: a request to locate or construct missing teaching material, such as outside sources, interview records, or a real-case packet. This is not supplied instruction. A tool activity with complete steps is still supplied instruction, even when an adult must prepare the device or account. An adult must select and verify materials, arrange access, and plan additional time first. Use the supplied card instead when those materials are unavailable.
Choose depth by readiness and interest, not age alone. Learners aged 10–12 can use the core teaching without taking every technical add-on; older-learner work remains optional. The depth questions are not prerequisites for the next core week or criteria for its checkpoint.
How to use a card
- Read the scenario and ask for a reasoned answer.
- Let the learner draw, speak, sort, or write using the fictional case.
- Compare with the sample: notice the evidence and the limits, not matching wording.
- If ready, change the stated assumption using the depth question.
- If the core idea is unclear, return to the linked lesson before adding complexity. A private or paper artifact is enough.
Sample responses illustrate reasoning, not scripts to memorize or the only defensible answer to an open choice. They do not require a learner to experience or disclose the situation.
Week 1
Core lesson: Week 1: Sunlight Detective (How Solar Energy Drives Everything)
Supplied scenario and question: Trace energy through Sun → leaf → rabbit. What is moving or changing?
Illustrative response: Sunlight energy supports plant growth and then can be transferred through food. Matter and energy have different paths; energy is not endlessly recycled in a closed loop.
Optional depth: Draw a separate matter arrow and an energy arrow and state where the simplified drawing leaves detail out.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 2
Core lesson: Week 2: Energy Changes Form (Energy Cannot Be Created or Destroyed)
Supplied scenario and question: An invented device receives 100 energy units, delivers 30 as useful motion, and transfers 70 as heat. Does energy disappear?
Illustrative response: No: 30 + 70 = 100. Heat is still energy, although it may be less useful for the intended task. The figures are a model, not a device specification.
Optional depth: Change useful motion to 40 with the same input and account for the remaining 60.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 3
Core lesson: Week 3: Build a Tiny World in a Jar (A Closed-Loop Micro-Ecosystem)
Supplied scenario and question: A sealed teaching terrarium receives light through glass. Is it closed to both matter and energy?
Illustrative response: It is approximately closed to matter while light and heat cross the boundary. A sealed boundary does not mean every flow is blocked.
Optional depth: Draw the boundary and distinguish internal water cycling from energy crossing it; do not disturb a real jar.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 4
Core lesson: Week 4: The Adventure of a Water Drop (How the Planet Moves Water)
Supplied scenario and question: A water drop evaporates, condenses, and falls as rain. Is each stage a new kind of matter?
Illustrative response: It is water changing state and moving between stores. The cycle does not guarantee that clean usable water appears instantly where people need it.
Optional depth: Add a delay or contamination path to the drawing and explain how it changes access.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 5
Core lesson: Week 5: Carbon the Shape-Shifter (How Carbon Moves Through Living Systems)
Supplied scenario and question: Connect fossil-fuel burning with atmospheric CO₂ and warming using two different arrow colors.
Illustrative response: Burning transfers stored carbon into air. Added CO₂ affects infrared energy escape and Earth’s energy balance; carbon matter does not create energy from nothing.
Optional depth: Explain why one cold local day cannot decide a global long-term trend, and why CO₂ is not a solid lid.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 6
Core lesson: Week 6: The Locked Food Plants Can't Open (The Nitrogen Cycle)
Supplied scenario and question: A plant is surrounded by air containing nitrogen, but cannot simply use most nitrogen gas directly. What conversion matters?
Illustrative response: Fixation changes nitrogen gas into usable compounds; other organisms and processes move nitrogen through soil and living things. Saying there is much nitrogen in air does not mean it is immediately usable.
Optional depth: Trace one plant–animal–soil route and distinguish conversion from creating new nitrogen matter.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 7
Core lesson: Week 7: There Is No Away (Tracing a Product's Complete Physical Journey)
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional bottle leaves a classroom bin and goes to sorting; the card says it is rejected there. Can we count it as recycled?
Illustrative response: No. Collection is one step, while actual recovery into usable material is another. Trace the rejected material’s next destination before saying the loop closed.
Optional depth: List a question to ask about the next facility rather than treating "away" as a physical endpoint.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 8
Core lesson: Week 8: How Much Is Too Much? (How Much Load Can a System Handle?)
Supplied scenario and question: In the supplied habitat model, removing leaf litter removes beetles’ habitat, frogs’ required cover, and birds’ food. What survives all listed needs?
Illustrative response: Only the bee type remains fully supported; the count falls from 4 modeled types to 1. Restoring leaf litter supports 4 again under the stated assumptions.
Optional depth: Add another bird food source and explain why the result changes; do not treat card counts as real population predictions.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 9
Core lesson: Week 9: Why Numbers Go Up and Down (What Happens When Demand Exceeds Supply)
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional population begins at 10; each step adds 4 and removes 2. Track two steps.
Illustrative response: It becomes 12, then 14. This net increase follows the given model; real populations also depend on resources, timing, and other conditions.
Optional depth: Change removal to 5 and compare the path 9, then 8 without changing the starting count.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 10
Core lesson: Week 10: The Shared Fish Pond Game (The Resource Pool Game)
Supplied scenario and question: A pretend pond starts at 20 tokens; each round takes 7 and regenerates 4. What is the stock after two rounds?
Illustrative response: 17 after one, 14 after two. Taking more than the stated replacement depletes the stock; cooperation rules can address the modeled flow.
Optional depth: Test taking 4 each round and explain the assumption that replacement remains 4.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 11
Core lesson: Week 11: Straight-Line Systems and Loop Systems
Supplied scenario and question: Compare take → make → discard with return → inspect → repair → use. Where is the return path?
Illustrative response: The second path feeds an item back into use if inspection and repair succeed. A drawing labeled circular does not prove every part actually returns.
Optional depth: Name a material or part the loop still cannot recover, and what evidence would verify recovery.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 12
Core lesson: Week 12: Can This Go Back Into a Loop? (How to Close an Open Loop)
Supplied scenario and question: A pretend marker body can be refilled, but its cap cannot be replaced. Is the whole product fully circular?
Illustrative response: The refill path closes one flow, but a failed cap can still end use. Identify each part and the actual return or replacement route.
Optional depth: Propose a replaceable cap and state the handling or quality check that would be needed.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 13
Core lesson: Week 13: Fix-It Detective (Designing for Disassembly and Reuse)
Supplied scenario and question: Two fictional toys have a removable screw cover versus a sealed glued cover. Which is easier to inspect for repair?
Illustrative response: The screw cover is designed for access, assuming safe tools and instructions. Easier disassembly alone does not prove a repair is safe or economical.
Optional depth: Compare replacement parts and instructions on paper; never open mains-powered, battery, or unsafe equipment for this task.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 14
Core lesson: Week 14: One Small Loop Challenge (Identifying and Fixing One Linear Process)
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional classroom discards usable scrap paper. Design one small return loop.
Illustrative response: Put clean usable scraps in a labeled drawing tray and check whether they are used again. The loop needs sorting and a destination, not only a new bin.
Optional depth: Name a contamination rule and one measure of actual reuse.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 15
Core lesson: Week 15: Turn Your Idea Into a Plan Someone Could Try
Supplied scenario and question: A scrap-paper plan says "Waste will fall a lot." The supplied baseline is 20 sheets discarded per meeting. Improve the goal.
Illustrative response: Choose a measurable trial goal, such as at most 15 discarded sheets under the same count. That would be 5 fewer, or 25% lower, if achieved.
Optional depth: Identify who must maintain the tray and which conditions need to stay comparable.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 16
Core lesson: Week 16: Make the Plan Real (What It Needs and What Gets in the Way)
Supplied scenario and question: The fictional tray needs a label, storage space, and a weekly sorter. What makes the proposal feasible?
Illustrative response: Specify each resource, its owner, and a check time; examine access and handling constraints. An appealing sketch is not an operating plan.
Optional depth: Add a failure mode, such as mixed wet paper, and a safe response.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 17
Core lesson: Week 17: Test Your Plan Like a Friendly Troublemaker
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional trial discarded 12 sheets versus a 20-sheet baseline. State the result and a limit.
Illustrative response: That is 8 fewer, or 40% lower, in the measured trial. The same counting boundary matters, and one trial does not prove a permanent effect.
Optional depth: Ask what changed besides the tray and propose a comparable next check.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 18
Core lesson: Week 18: Share Your Plan With Someone Real
Supplied scenario and question: Share the fictional scrap-paper proposal with a drawn audience card instead of contacting a real person. What is a complete explanation?
Illustrative response: State the problem, return path, roles, measured trial, uncertainty, and next step. Distinguish actual results from targets and model values.
Optional depth: Include one affected user’s need; a real public pitch is optional, and a paper/private presentation can show the learning.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.